you're reading...

Are Our Schools Really Failing Our Children…?

Or are they just doing the same as they’ve always done…?

It’s a question that jumped to mind when I read a post by Kevin Drum where he questions the assertion that high school students are worse prepared than they were in the past and provides this chart as evidence that the logic behind that thought might be flawed…

Now, there are lots of ways to read this chart.  We could focus on the fact that the gap between whites and minorities has not been closed.  We could also focus on why scores shot up in the early 80s for minorities as a potential starting point for determining what solutions we might seek to emulate today.

But my eye just keeps finding it’s way back to the relative stability of the scores post 1980.  Now, some may say that this is misleading because the tests are not the same as in 1980 and have gotten easier.  Perhaps…I really don’t know.  But absent that explanation, it doesn’t seem like high schools and their students are performing any worse than they were 30 years ago.

So why all the commotion and attention now?

Well, one thought that I have is that NEAP captures all students – that is, those in public and private schools.  In fact, their sample reads as follows:

Who are the students assessed by NAEP?

The national results are based on a representative sample of students in public schools, private schools,Bureau of Indian Education schools, and Department of Defense schools. Private schools include Catholic, Conservative Christian, Lutheran, and other private schools.

And clearly, when people talk about schools being in crisis, they are pointing towards public schools.  But based on the chart above, it seems entirely plausible, potentially likely even, that this crisis in public schools is not so much a result of schools getting worse as much as it is the mix of students changing…

That is to say that as higher performing white students have fled public schools for private schools, the national average scores may stay the same, but public schools, now with a higher concentration of lower performing minority students are now doing worse.

Now, that’s relatively simple math.  Schools, teachers and students may not be doing any worse than they did before.  This is important to acknowledge because what’s been portrayed has been the exact opposite.  And while I don’t think that this simple math should stop efforts to improve learning, I do think it should inform these efforts.  We can still say that what’s being done is not good enough (clearly it’s not good enough as the white-minority gap remains), but context is essential to getting the right answers to the problem, determining the right sources to spur improvement and avoiding simplifications or false foundations for arguments.



2 thoughts on “Are Our Schools Really Failing Our Children…?

  1. My (admittedly flip) reaction – yes, public school performance has been uniformly terrible and unacceptable for our kids (particularly students of color) for 32yrs+.

    Posted by John G | June 21, 2012, 5:36 pm
    • i hear you. agree. if it’s not good enough now, it wasn’t good enough 30 years ago either. and it’s not good enough now. i guess as i think about it, the question i start to ask myself is whether the entire education system doesnt even know how to educate students of color? if that’s the case, the issue is a lot bigger than incentives for individual teachers and even finding “good” teachers.

      i guess what i’m wondering is if the failure of attempts to address all of these issues, of which education is one, but also include things like poverty, obesity, etc all originate from a lack of understanding of the communities one is trying to assist?

      Posted by chico | June 21, 2012, 11:17 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Be Our Twitter Friend



%d bloggers like this: